Yamaha R1 Forum: YZF-R1 Forums banner
1 - 10 of 10 Posts

· The One
Joined
·
151 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hello Guys,

I wasnt going to post this article because I find the conclusions a provocation to you, but as I was reading some post on the Gixxer Forum I found a guy asking for this shootout...

The Guy Knick name was Clova R1 and in the Gixxer forum he owns a 01 Gixxer 1000...I suppose it's the same guy who criticised me for buying a Gixxer, the same guy that didnt care about Hp or Top Speeds...Therefore not the ClovaR1 you know!


:confused:

Here you have the comparo:fact
Round Three: Straight-Line Stoopidity!
By the Motorcycle Online Staff

Palmdale, California, April 5, 2002 --

You want real-world testing? It hasn't been this real-world for me since I got rid of the '67 Chevelle, pal: Los Angeles County Raceway, Wednesday Grudge Night. I had no grudge going in, or did I? Minime had applied a sound thrashing at Fontana last Friday....

I forgot how much fun drag racing is. The cars are a little different now--all sorts of Hondas and things--but still enough old Camaros and Falcons to divert my glance, occasionally, from all the bare-midriffed high-school sweetheart types milling about, who the socks I was wearing predate. The LA crowd likes to deride the desert-dwelling Palmdalians, and now I realize it can only be about LA's envy over having no drag strip. I don't remember them ever letting dates ride shotgun when I used to torture-test drum brakes in my 427 Chevelle, or maybe I just never had dates? Anyway, we sat next to the same young couple in a yellow '68 Mustang quite a few times in the staging lanes. Before the first run, the blonde cutie in the passenger seat looked a little tense; after about the third, our boy was enjoying back-rub action in the driver's seat waiting for the next pass. Young love, sighhh... Next time your girlfriend/wife/whatever says you never take her anywhere, rent a Hertz Mustang, "thow the top down, and take the wench drag racing--$15 a car. I axe you, is there any finer entertainment bargain? The cheese burgers aren't too bad either.



The MO staff, however, was not here to play. We were here for serious business, and, at great personal risk, took it upon ourselves yet again to plumb the performance parameters of our three contestants in this, the final showdown, the Freakness Preakness, for the coveted Open-class crown.

The youngsters were a tad apprehensive, but all that evaporated after the first couple of smoky tire warmings. Drag racing is pure, stupid, forget-your-troubles Fun--well, it is when you're riding completely stock bikes that feel damn near unbreakable. (The Chevelle used to find at least one thing to break every time: rocker arm, clutch, wheel....)

On with it then: the Suzuki kicked their butts again. Matter of fact, I think MY, NOT MINI's, 10.51 second, 137 mph pass, kicked the butt of every vehicle in the place that night. Minime said it best, when he said "the only way the Honda or Yamaha will beat that thing in a drag race, is if they pull into its draft off the line, then slip-stream past at the end." Unfortunately, drafting is a no-no at the strip.



I made ten runs on the GSX-R if I made one, also on the Honda, likewise aboard the Yamaha. So did Calvin, so did Minime. We tried different launch techniques and rpm, different tire preparations, different religious rituals. And, at the end of it, we still sucked. Actually I wouldn't say we sucked, I'd say these numbers are way more in line with what the average, casual drag racer might achieve himself, compared to the numbers you read in the magazines (which are achieved at the cost, usually, of a fragged clutch or two and a bunch of passes in search of the perfect one).

This, at the end of the evening is where we arrived (corrected for Palmdale's altitude):

The Times, The Points
GSX-R1000 CBR-954RR YZF-R1

JohnnyB 10.51 @ 137.16 (3pts) 10.94 @ 128.76 (1pts) 10.82 @ 128.65 (2pts)
Minime 10.75 @ 136.70 (3pts) 10.90 @ 128.72 (2pts) 10.93 @ 128.90 (1pts)
Hackfu 10.89 @ 136.94 (3pts) 11.00 @ 127.67 (2pts) 11.02 @ 129.49 (1pts)

Average Time/Total Points 10.72 @ 136.93 (9pts) 10.94 @ 128.38 (5pts) 10.92 @ 129.10 (4pts)

For those of you who will whine, regardless or irregardless, here are the figures you'll read in your June Cycle World, as arrived at by the lovely and very fast Don Canet:
Don Canet 9.95 @ 143.69 10.32 @ 138.12 10.32 @ 137.60




There are various lessons in here for all of us. One is that fast guys go faster. Two is that whatever your talent level, you go faster on a faster bike. Three is, these things are all Howitzer-proof; we tired out before the bikes did (not sure about Canet's test fleet, though). Four, Minime's got no answer when I'm on my game--NO ANSWER! As far as one bike being easier to "launch" than others, I, JB, had no preference, really--though it was amazingly difficult to pull my left foot up to shift into second when I got it right on the GSX-R. You can feel that three-tenths of a second more muscle in the left front quadrant of your sphincter. Careful on the Honda; with the front wheel skimming the ripples at the top of first gear, its bars will get lively. The Yamaha remains user-friendly, and the blue shift light is just the ticket for howling toward the timing lights through a star-filled, dark desert. Most fun we've had since last Friday at Fontana.

--JB

Running total (street plus track plus drag-strip points):

Suzuki GSX-R1000: 23 pts
Honda CBR954RR: 20 pts
Yamaha YZF-R1: 17 pts

Minime said it the best:

"Honda's a bit tricky to launch and shakes its head like a Mofo if you're not ON the tank. Suzuki just has so much motor, the launch doesn't matter. Yamaha is somewhere in between, and maybe easiest to launch well."

:lol
 

· Silver Stealth Pilot
Joined
·
163 Posts
Pedro, WE KNOW the gixxer has more power, but so does a GARBAGE TRUCK !!!.

I think you are having 02 R1 withdrawal :D since you cancelled your order coz you couldn't really afford the extra over the Gixxer. (You got it cheap from what I heard from the boyz at Gixxer.com!!)

Incidentally, have you read this (take out speech marks):-

'http://www.gixxer.com/forums/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=007259'

:butt :butt :butt

Fly

PS. If you sell it now you may just have half the deposit on that ultimate liquid silver 02 you always wanted :D :D
 

· The One
Joined
·
151 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Flystar said:
Pedro, WE KNOW the gixxer has more power, but so does a GARBAGE TRUCK !!!.

I think you are having 02 R1 withdrawal :D since you cancelled your order coz you couldn't really afford the extra over the Gixxer. (You got it cheap from what I heard from the boyz at Gixxer.com!!)

Incidentally, have you read this (take out speech marks):-

'http://www.gixxer.com/forums/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=007259'

:butt :butt :butt

Fly

PS. If you sell it now you may just have half the deposit on that ultimate liquid silver 02 you always wanted :D :D
I paid exactly the same for the Gixxer as if I bought the R1, its just that I choosed the best bike, more power, more corner stability, sounds nicer, etc...
Concerning the comments of 1 guy at the Gixxer forum, you may also read many guys here complaining about the ticking on the engine,etc...
My 98 R1 was returned to Yamaha due to a problem in the clutch, my 00 R1 had heating problems, so dont tell me that its reliable:finger
 

· Nothin' sexier than an R1
Joined
·
513 Posts
PEDRO....SUCK IT:bash
 

· Ree-peat 0-fender
Joined
·
1,321 Posts
Pedro,

You must be totally brain dead, on any given day depending on the rider any 3 of these bikes can beat one another.

As always it comes down to the rider's skill, all of these bikes according to all the experts each have their own strengths and weaknesses and are nearly identical in performance.

In your eyes you picked the bike that attracted you the most, not necessarily that it's THE BEST all around.

The GSXR1000 is a nice bike, but lets face it Honda and Yamaha at least know how to put a pipe on that looks like it cost more than a $1.50.

The GSXR1000 in my opinion is not the better street bike for the long haul and I have ridden all 3. It's punishing and not nearly as form fitting as a Honda or Yamaha.

Go gnaw on that for a while...:no
 

· Pegs are made for draggin'
Joined
·
272 Posts
Oddly the other thing about this review is that the first two guys, out of three, stated straight up that they would pick the R1 if they could only have 1. That tells you that there is something about the R1 that wasn't valued in the test that makes it better than the others!

Me, I am sticking with my R1. My d!$% is big enough that I don't need the extra couple ponies to feel like a man.

J
 

· My dog ate my R1
Joined
·
227 Posts
my $.02:

Most of the people here will never see the track. These bikes are street ridden. If you are riding these bikes on the street at such a point where you can really notice the performance differences between the two.....I am scared for you. The gixxer does pull harder, but does that 3/10's of a second really matter? Not to me because i value my license and my low insurance rates (192.00/year for full coverage)....

They are BOTH great bikes capable of more than most riders will ever extract.
 

· Nothin' sexier than an R1
Joined
·
513 Posts
How do you get full coverage for under $200/year???
Please let me know!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
456 Posts
A little distressing

I have been off for about a week and see it's the same old s**t with the Gixxer vs the new R-1.:butt
I appreciate Pedro posting the story, and it's about what I figured the open class shootout would get down to. Sometimes a guy just has to roll up that hanging lower lip and admit it when he gets whupped:p and quit acting like crybabies:cryin because the mags somehow comeup with the conclusions that in every objective measure of speed, HOWEVER you want to define it..................... the Gixxer jumps up and down on the competetion:fact
I wouldn't trade straight across for the Gixxer myself because I think they are bigtime FUGLY, bland and uninspiring. I can hardly go by my bike in the garage without wanting to mess with something on the bike, it's kind of magnetic that way. Besides, I REALLY enjoy motoring away from my m8's on Gixxers when we all KNOW it's the sharper tool, eh? ;)
The gixxer wins the shootouts, that's :cool: , I think it's good form to ceed that fact, and enjoy the best integated , prettiest mass produced sportbikes the Japanese have ever produced, even if, subjectively they are down a little on foot speed;)
 

· Buffoon: 65 on Squid Test
Joined
·
1,403 Posts
Wicked said:
How do you get full coverage for under $200/year???
Please let me know!!
www.gmac123.com

I pay something like $190 a year for the R1, $367 total for two bikes. I'm 44, had a motorcycle license for almost 30 years, own a house and have a good driving record. Plus my Chico zip code alone is probably worth insurance rates 40% less than yours in the Bay Area.

BTW, not to get into the chicken strips discussions, but when I took the bike in for 600 mile service, the tech said, "Holy shit! Is this guy racing? You don't get wear all the way up the side on the street." The service manager let him know the bike already saw a (very gentle) day at the track.
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top