Yamaha R1 Forum: YZF-R1 Forums banner

The first Australian to be executed in 12 years

5.2K views 138 replies 30 participants last post by  Sook  
#1 ·
The first Australian to be executed in 12 years


By Steve Butcher and Connie Levett in Singapore
December 2, 2005



NGUYEN TUONG VAN could only hold his mother's hand in his final hours. They were not allowed to hug or kiss.

Nguyen's mother, Kim, and his twin brother, Khoa, were granted special permission to touch him as they said their last goodbyes yesterday at Singapore's Changi prison, but he had to face the end without them.

He was not completely alone, however. In his hands he held a string of rosary beads and by his side, comforting him, were the prison's priest and the guards. He prayed and was at peace with his world, only saddened that he was leaving behind people who would be heartbroken by his death at 9am Sydney time.

The last Australian executed was Sydney man Michael McAuliffe, who was hanged in Malaysia in 1993, also on heroin charges.

Nguyen spent about six hours with his brother, mother and friends Kelly Ng and Bronwyn Lew. Ms Nguyen had to be helped out of the prison afterwards and all four were too distraught last night to say what took place.

It is understood a perspex wall separated them from Nguyen and they held his hand through a grille box, the type used to pass items to prisoners.

The Singaporean Government said it did not usually allow physical contact because "such encounters can be traumatic and can destabilise the prisoner and their family".

The concession was made after a personal appeal from the Prime Minister, John Howard, to his Singaporean counterpart, Lee Hsien Loong at the weekend. The Foreign Affairs Minister, Alexander Downer, described it as "meagre compensation".

Nguyen has been humbled by the support he has received during his three years in jail for drug smuggling. His writing hand would have still been weary from the last letters he hurriedly finished to his loved ones and friends. The 25-year-old from Melbourne was determined to die with strength and optimism - and to remain, in his own words, "one cool guy". He had photographs taken of himself in different suits and poses and had them handed to his mother. He was clear about the way he wanted to be remembered.

The injustice many feel at his execution was conveyed in a measured but pointed tone by one of his barristers, Julian McMahon. He reminded everyone - and the Singaporean Government, which repeatedly refused Nguyen clemency - that his client was rehabilitated, reformed and "focused on doing what is good".

"And now they are going to kill him," he told media outside Changi yesterday morning.

Mr McMahon, who was joined by his colleagues Lex Lasry, QC, and Joseph Thesiera, said: "We have just been with a young man who is in a beautiful state of mind. He is cheerful.

"What I wish to say is that he is a beautiful young man. Cheerful because he is composed. He only wishes to think good thoughts, say good things, do what is right."

Mr Lasry said the legal team had just "looked into the eyes of a healthy young 25-year-old with so much to offer, who is going to die a violent death". "I just want to say we've had a beautiful visit. We are not going to answer questions. We may talk about it later. That's all I want to say. It was a great visit and quite uplifting."

Later he told ABC TV's 7.30 Report: "It's the hardest thing I have ever had to do in my career." He said he would readily take on other death penalty cases "in his memory ... It would be great to be able to tell his story to other people. He's become a beacon for young people who might be tempted to be exploited in this way to overcome the temptation and to transform their lives."

The Australian high commission was on hand to offer Nguyen's family and friends support throughout the day, and picked them up from the prison at 6.30pm Singapore time.

Khoa was the first to come through Changi's glass doors. Dressed in white, he looked sober and ran his fingers through his hair as he got into the first of two waiting consular cars. His mother came next, flanked by Mr McMahon and a consular official, Annette Morris. A headscarf hid Ms Nguyen's face but she was clearly crushed and had to be almost carried to the car.

Inside, with her son, she was comforted by Mr Lasry's wife, Elizabeth. Ms Ng and Ms Lew left last, Ms Lew sobbing as they got into the second car.

Speaking yesterday morning, Mr Lasry said there was less humour between him and Nguyen than on Wednesday. There was some laughter "but not much".

Nguyen had never blamed anyone, felt resentment or expressed any anger.

Mr Lasry said: "He is emotional, as we all are ... I think he's frightened, but not overly frightened, frightened of the actual act of being killed.

"His overwhelming ... feeling he portrays is strength."

He revealed that Nguyen would be supported in his last hours by a priest and his guards. "They treat him like a son. They'll be there with him [and] there's going to be some men in uniform who are going to be very upset tomorrow morning."

The crime
Nguyen Tuong Van, 25, was arrested at Changi Airport with 396.2 grams of heroin strapped to his body. His botched smuggling run was meant to generate cash to pay the debts of his drug-addicted twin.

The punishment
Singapore's drug laws stipulate execution for those caught with more than 15 grams of heroin. The Government insists Nguyen was not a pawn but a criminal with enough drugs to ruin thousands of lives.

-
 
#2 ·
What do you guys think? Is this right or wrong?

The way I see it nobody makes you take drugs.

Is it any worse then legal drugs and alcohol which kill and ruin just as many lives. Smoking is the number one killer but we don't hang tabacco CEO's
 
#3 ·
good riddents drug dealer:machinegu imagine if the fcker had of got away with 75,000 hits of heroin? he'd be livin in a big house with a bmw and we'd all go wow he must work hard for his money.... yeah right... how many losers do i see every day that have gotten away with the very same $hit:mad: hope the suck burns in hell.:fact
 
#4 ·
He said he did it to get his twin brother out of debt.



Nguyen Tuong Van, 25, was arrested at Changi Airport with 396.2 grams of heroin strapped to his body. His botched smuggling run was meant to generate cash to pay the debts of his drug-addicted twin.
 
#5 ·
Guess he should have checked the laws where he was committing the crime first.

Too bad.

Its a shame his brothers habit is what killed him. I love my brothers too but I'm not about to commit any crimes to help them with their problems. I bet a lot of people are re-thinking their drug smuggling plans through Singapore right now
 
#6 ·
r1gladiator said:
He said he did it to get his twin brother out of debt.



Nguyen Tuong Van, 25, was arrested at Changi Airport with 396.2 grams of heroin strapped to his body. His botched smuggling run was meant to generate cash to pay the debts of his drug-addicted twin.
yeah fancy that!:cryin druggys ALWAYS have piss poor excuses.:fact rot in hell scum i say.:boom
 
#8 ·
GO!!!!!!R6 said:
i think that is a bit harsh , know boby makes peolpe that drugs , and i think death for this criem is wrong
:bs how many kids lives would have been fcked up with 75.000 doses of heroin??? thats the reason his dopey brother was in trouble in the first place:fact . vicious circle isn't it? he got what was coming to him... again rot in hell scum junkie dealer.:eek:wwn3d
 
#10 ·
Lord_Phat said:
of course those kids have no personal responsibility, it's all the fault of the evil drug dealers :sleep
why does everyone feel sorry for that P.O.S?.. anyway he wont be "hanging" around long anyway!:lol :lol :eek:wwn3d
 
#11 ·
r1gladiator said:
He said he did it to get his twin brother out of debt.
Nguyen Tuong Van, 25, was arrested at Changi Airport with 396.2 grams of heroin strapped to his body. His botched smuggling run was meant to generate cash to pay the debts of his drug-addicted twin.
Then his brother should have made the run then!:fact

Voodoo
 
#13 ·
Lord_Phat said:
where did i say i felt sorry for him? :confused:

i think the death penalty is a tad overzealous for drug trafficing, tis all :fact
you're right it should have been torture- then death. bring back firing squads.:machinegu :boom
 
#14 ·
Lord_Phat said:
where did i say i felt sorry for him? :confused:

i think the death penalty is a tad overzealous for drug trafficing, tis all :fact
Im not taking sides here, but that law has been in force for EVER!!!! He knew the chances when he took the chance correct?

Get away with it, make it big!

Get caught, die!:(

Somewhere he got the feeling that his % of getting away with it were very high!

Voodoo
 
#15 ·
VoodooDsims said:
Im not taking sides here, but that law has been in force for EVER!!!! He knew the chances when he took the chance correct?

Get away with it, make it big!

Get caught, die!:(

Somewhere he got the feeling that his % of getting away with it were very high!

Voodoo
Not to smart but then the laws a real dumb.

The punishment
Singapore's drug laws stipulate execution for those caught with more than 15 grams of heroin. The Government insists Nguyen was not a pawn but a criminal with enough drugs to ruin thousands of lives.

So what he should have done is smuggle 10 grams twice. If he got caught with 10 grams Its only life in prison:crash
 
#17 ·
r1gladiator said:
Not to smart but then the laws a real dumb.

The punishment
Singapore's drug laws stipulate execution for those caught with more than 15 grams of heroin. The Government insists Nguyen was not a pawn but a criminal with enough drugs to ruin thousands of lives.

So what he should have done is smuggle 10 grams twice. If he got caught with 10 grams Its only life in prison:crash
Maybe the law is dumb but I'm sure he knew it? No one will front you that kind of weight without knowing the law!

And your correct, he sould have done 10 grams X 2! Get caught once and NEVER return!

Voodoo
 
#18 ·
Unsure about the death penalty. But then again, why should tax payers have to pay for monsters such as rapists, serial killers, drug dealers etc. This guy did the deed and payed the ultimate price. You must respect a countries laws, however barabaric they may seem. People from singapore wonder what all the fuss is about, they accept the death penalty for what it is.
 
#19 ·
VoodooDsims said:
Maybe the law is dumb but I'm sure he knew it? No one will front you that kind of weight without knowing the law!

And your correct, he sould have done 10 grams X 2! Get caught once and NEVER return!

Voodoo
Hey I heard on CNN Singapore was just a stop over as he was headed to OZ to sell the drugs. Should have got a direct flight, ant that a biatch

CNN just in he's dead now. :(
 
#20 ·
r1gladiator said:
Hey I heard on CNN Singapore was just a stop over as he was headed to OZ to sell the drugs. Should have got a direct flight, ant that a biatch

CNN just in he's dead now. :(
As we say in the "White collor" world"

"Lack of planning on HIS part, does not consitute and emergency on Singapour's part!"

Sad, but maybe a direct flight was his answer!

Voodoo
 
#21 ·
r1gladiator said:
Hey I heard on CNN Singapore was just a stop over as he was headed to OZ to sell the drugs. Should have got a direct flight, ant that a biatch

CNN just in he's dead now. :(
:jump :rock :jump .....:eek:wwn3d
 
#22 ·
In an unusual set of circumstances I find myself in agreement with LP (proving a stopped clock can be right twice a day or in this case an Australian ;) ). The death penalty is barbaric.

This is a very tough area of the law in that there are times when the circumstances of the crime are so heinous that it seems to scream for the death penalty but there is no way drug smuggling could be veiwed so harshly.
 
#26 · (Edited)
well

I agree that he knew the risks, so how should he be surprised? BUT this law singapore runs is a hoax, as it's been said during this that they execute people for "ruining people's lives" (that as Phat says, nobody is holding them down and throwing needles at them, and besides, Keith Code seems ok to me, don't you think?)BUT it states people of singapores lives and so, being on his way here, had no bearing on Singapore etc. Add to that the Singapore govt spendsmillions if not more a year with a company that is owned by the biggest drug lord of that area, gladly and wingingly, yet kills the people running it, it just plain ***t up and wrong. Again, he knew the punishment, and I'd be ***t if I'd be running that through there knowing those laws, BUT does the punishment fit the crime? Seems to me that drug runners and people that steal money from major companies and Govts (that rort everyone harder than they are ever rorted themselves, lets face it) seem to get hit hard with the full force of the law, YET you can bash, rape murder etc etc people and get away with a year or two in jail, or even a behaviur bonds etc. THAT is what is wrong.



PS Has Singapore banned smoking? LOL OH right they don't wreck millions of lives at ALL.